Resources On The Controversy Over “Final Salvation Through Works”

by on October 22, 2017 | 6 Comments

For the last several years several writers identified with the broader Reformed movement have proposed that Christians are saved initially by grace alone, through faith alone but finally through faith and works. There are two claims here: 1)  salvation is in two stages and 2)  the instruments in each stage differ. Second, some have alleged that these doctrines are the doctrines of the Reformed tradition. So we have exegetical, theological, historical, and practical questions: If one’s present salvation is merely provisional, which is logically necessary if there are two stages, what is the basis of one’s assurance? Of course assurance of faith or assurance of salvation is vitiated, and should these proposals stand, every Christian is, with Martin Luther, in a monastic cell in Eurfurt wondering if he will perform works of sufficient number and quality finally to enter heaven. Here are some resources to help you work through these questions.

Table Of Contents

  1. Podcasts
  2. Articles
  3. Sources
  4. Other Resources

Podcasts

  1. The Reformed Brotherhood: Overcoming Confirmation Bias On Piper And Final Salvation Through Works
  2. Heidelcast Series On Nomism And Antinomianism
  3. Office Hours: The Gospel Mystery of Sanctification
  4. Heidelcast Series: God’s Holy Law
  5. Heidelcast Series On Romans
  6. Heidelcast 208—Taking Calls On Church Discipline For Doctrinal Error, Final Salvation Through Works, Divinization, Justice, Ecstatic Worship, And Providence
  7. Heidelcast For July 3, 2022: A Mailbag Episode (including a segment on sola fide versus Piper’s doctrine of salvation)
  8. See It For Yourself: Piper On Wilson, Baptism, And The FV + 2 early Heidelcast episodes: A Gentle Rebuke To Brother John
  9. With Megiddo Radio On John Piper’s Doctrine of Final Salvation By Works
  10. Dr R. Scott Clark – Final Salvation Controversy 01
  11. With Megiddo Radio On The Current Justification Controversy
  12. Heidelcast 149: Q & A On How Pray, When To Drop The H Bomb, What Did OT Believers Know, And Why Final Justification Through Good Works Is Bad News
  13. Heidelcast 152: Calls On Church History, Theocracy, Biblical Languages, Final Salvation Through Works, Jesus’ Faith, And Civil Disobedience

Articles

  1. R. Scott Clark, We Attain Heaven Through Faith Alone
  2. William Edison, Faith, Love, and Piper: Distinguishing Reformed Categories
  3. Rachel Green Miller, Salvation By Grace Alone, Through Faith Alone, In Christ Alone
  4. D. G. Hart, Easy Obeyism
  5. W. Robert Godfrey, Faith Formed By Love Or Faith Alone? The Instrument Of Justification
  6. Kyle Grow, The Necessity Of Good Works: Ursinus’ Exposition Of Heidelberg 64
  7. Harrison Perkins, Engaging Piper’s New Book: Are Affections Part Of Saving Faith? A Review of What Is Saving Faith? by John Piper
  8. Guy P. Waters, Faith and Treasuring Christ: A Review Article
  9. R. Scott Clark, Should We Allow Wesleyans To Narrate The Reformed Tradition For Us? (Or Why We Are Not Finally Saved Through Good Works) Part 1
  10. R. Scott Clark, Should We Allow Wesleyans To Narrate The Reformed Tradition For Us (Or Why We Are Not Finally Saved Through Good Works) Part 2
  11. R. Scott Clark, Faith Alone Is The Instrument Of Justification And Salvation
  12. R. Scott Clark, Piper Makes Final Salvation A Covenant of Works
  13. R. Scott Clark, Salvation Sola Gratia, Sola Fide: Distinguishing Is, With, And Through
  14. R. Scott Clark, The Heidelberg Catechism Confesses Salvation By Grace Alone, Through Faith Alone
  15. R. Scott Clark, Saved Through Good Works?
  16. R. Scott Clark, Believers Are Not Out On Bail
  17. R. Scott Clark, Jesus: Your Faith Has Saved You
  18. R. Scott Clark, The Shield of Works? Faith, Spiritual Warfare, and Salvation
  19. R. Scott Clark, Believers Are Saved And Sealed
  20. R. Scott Clark, In By Grace, Stay In By Faithfulness?
  21. R. Scott Clark, Heidelcast 98: Salvation, Good Works, And Conditions
  22. R. Scott Clark, Muddying The Distinction Between Justification And Salvation
  23. R. Scott Clark, Justification By Faith Alone Is The Normative Reformed Doctrine
  24. R. Scott Clark, Sola Fides is Not Sola Fide
  25. R. Scott Clark, An Important Distinction Between Kinds And Functions Of Conditions
  26. R. Scott Clark, What Is True Faith? The Romanist Condemnation Of True Faith
  27. R. Scott Clark, Brothers, We Are Not Perfectionists
  28. R. Scott Clark, Justification And Vindication
  29. R. Scott Clark, What Is True Faith? A Glorious Omission
  30. R. Scott Clark, After the Federal Vision: The Return of Moralism
  31. R. Scott Clark, The Consensus of the Divines, Legalism, And The Covenant Of Works
  32. R. Scott Clark, The Logic Of Fruit As Evidence
  33. R. Scott Clark, Justified Through Our Faithfulness?
  34. R. Scott Clark, The Reasons Christians Do Good Works
  35. R. Scott Clark, Witsius And Turretin On The Necessity And Efficacy Of Good Works In Salvation
  36. R. Scott Clark, Did Ursinus Teach Final Salvation And That Through Works?
  37. R. Scott Clark, Daniel Fuller: The Background To The Current Salvation Controversy
  38. R. Scott Clark, The Question Is Not Whether Believers Do Good Works But Why
  39. R. Scott Clark, Believer, You Are Being Graciously Sanctified
  40. R. Scott Clark, Why Should I Love God?
  41. R. Scott Clark, There Is Only One Stage Of Justification
  42. R. Scott Clark, Dort On Election, Conditions, And Fruit
  43. R. Scott Clark, The Impenitent Cannot Be Saved
  44. R. Scott Clark, Will We Be Finally “Saved” By Faith Alone (sola fide)?
  45. R. Scott Clark, Piper’s Rejection Of The Gratitude Ethic Is A Rejection Of The Reformation

Sources

  1. Yes, He Really Does Teach Final Salvation Through Works
  2. Perkins: Salvation, All Of It, Is By Grace Alone, Through Faith Alone
  3. Baugh: Ephesians 2:8 Presents Salvation As Completed
  4. Baugh On Ephesians 2:9: Good Works Are From Not Unto Salvation
  5. Machen: Salvation is By Grace Alone, Through Faith Alone
  6. Godfrey: Salvation Sola Fide Versus Salvation By Faith Formed By Love
  7. Was Calvin A Lutheran?
  8. Berkhof On What Sense Works Are Said To Be Necessary In Salvation
  9. Calvin On Salvation By Grace Alone Through Faith Alone
  10. Why We Remember The Reformation (1)
  11. Why We Remember The Reformation (2)
  12. Why We Remember the Reformation (3).
  13. J. G. Vos On Salvation And Good Works in WLC 32
  14. Berkhof On Salvation And Good Works
  15. Dort: Things We May Not Say About Salvation
  16. Perkins: Grace Admits No Partner
  17. Turretin: We Do Good Works Because We Live By The Gospel
  18. Olevianus On The State Of Believers In The Judgment
  19. Hodge: Christ Fulfilled The Condition Of The Covenant Of Works For Believers
  20. Machen: Salvation Through Faith Vs. Salvation Through Love
  21. The Principal Acts Of Saving Faith
  22. Witsius: The Law Of Works And The Law Of Faith Are Antecedent And Consequent Conditions
  23. Goodwin: Salvation Is Through Faith Alone But Good Works Are A Necessary Consequence
  24. Goodwin: Faith Alone Is The Condition Of The Covenant Of Grace
  25. Goodwin: Faith Does It All
  26. Witsius: Good Works Are Necessary Effects And Evidences Of Salvation
  27. Olevianus: Salvation Is By Grace Alone Or Christ Is But Half A Savior
  28. Vos On The Role Of Works In Salvation
  29. Perkins: Faith Is The Instrument Of Salvation
  30. Sproul: Why Can’t We Say Good Works Are Necessary As Evidence?
  31. Richard Baxter on Initial and Final Justification
  32. The Bible Presbyterian Church Rejects Two-Stage Justification and Final Justification Through Works
  33. Marrowmen: Our Good Works Are Not Instrumental Or Causal In Our Justification Or Salvation
  34. Brakel: It Is Contrary To The Reformed Confession To Say Justification Is Acquired By Good Works
  35. Piper’s Doctrine Of Final Salvation Through Works: The Reformed Brotherhood Understands Your Pain
  36. Colquhoun Contra Final Salvation Through Works
  37. Colquhoun: The Whole Salvation Is Freely Offered
  38. How Baxter Came To Reject The Reformation Doctrine Of Salvation
  39. How Virtue Ethics Helps Address Final Salvation Through Works
  40. Piper’s New Book Is Edwardsian
  41. Ursinus Anticipated And Rejected Final Salvation Through Works
  42. Initial Justification Sola Fide And Final Salvation Through Faithfulness Is Federal Vision Theology
  43. “Final Salvation” Through Faith AND Fruit Is Not Reformation Doctrine

Other Resources

  1. Resources On Richard Baxter
  2. Resources On The Reformation Solas
  3. Resources On The Doctrine Of Justification
  4. Resources On Keeping Justification And Sanctification Together Without Confusing Them
  5. Resources On the Doctrine of Sanctification And The Third Use Of The Law
  6. Resources on the Law/Gospel Distinction

RESOURCES

Heidelberg Reformation Association
1637 E. Valley Parkway #391
Escondido CA 92027
USA
The HRA is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization

    Post authored by:

  • R. Scott Clark
    Author Image

    R.Scott Clark is the President of the Heidelberg Reformation Association, the author and editor of, and contributor to several books and the author of many articles. He has taught church history and historical theology since 1997 at Westminster Seminary California. He has also taught at Wheaton College, Reformed Theological Seminary, and Concordia University. He has hosted the Heidelblog since 2007.

    More by R. Scott Clark ›

Subscribe to the Heidelblog today!


6 comments

  1. “For the last several years several writers identified with the broader Reformed movement have proposed that Christians are saved initially by grace alone, through faith alone but finally through faith and works.”

    I’m pretty sure I know the name of one of these writers, but would you list a few names? It’s not always straight forward to spot who’s teaching this since they use reformed language but have a different working definition of some key terms.
    Thanks!

  2. What a tremendous treasure we Reformed have in our Three Forms of unity, to provide us with a firm foundation in sound doctrine. False teachers are trying to scare us with the threat of being judged, when Christ returns, that we will be judged on the evidence of our works for our final right standing before God. But the truth is that Christ has already been judged in the place of those who trust in Him, and vindicated. So are His people, and they will join Him in glory on the last day. We can look ahead to that day with full confidence because we are as righteous as Christ himself. There is your true incentive to do good works.

  3. Let me ask 3 questions:

    1. Will believers appear before the Lord at the final judgment?

    2. If the answer is no, what do you do with the texts that appear to indicate believers appearing before the Lord at the final judgment?

    3. If answer is yes, then for what will they give an account? what about them will the Lord judge?

    • Heidelberg Catechism:

      10. Will God suffer such disobedience and apostasy to go unpunished?

      By no means, but He is terribly displeased with our inborn as well as our actual sins, and will punish them in just judgment in time and eternity, as He has declared: “Cursed is every one who continues not in all things which are written in the Book of the Law to do them.”

      12. Since then by the righteous judgment of God we deserve temporal and eternal punishment, how may we escape this punishment and be again received into favor?

      God wills that His justice be satisfied; therefore we must make full satisfaction to the same, either by ourselves or by another.

      38. Why did He suffer “under Pontius Pilate” as judge?

      That He, being innocent, might be condemned by the temporal judge, and thereby deliver us from the severe judgment of God, to which we were exposed.

      46. How do you understand the words: “He ascended into heaven”?

      That Christ, in the sight of His disciples, was taken up from the earth into heaven; and continues there in our behalf2 until He shall come again to judge the living and the dead.

      52. What comfort is it to you, that Christ “shall come to judge the living and the dead”?

      That in all my sorrows and persecutions, with uplifted head, I look for the very same one, who before offered Himself for me to the judgment of God, and removed all curse from me, to come as Judge from heaven, who shall cast all His and my enemies into everlasting condemnation, but shall take me with all His chosen ones to Himself into heavenly joy and glory.

      56. What do you believe concerning the “forgiveness of sins”?

      That God, for the sake of Christ’s satisfaction, will no more remember my sins, nor the sinful nature with which I have to struggle all my life long; but graciously imputes to me the righteousness of Christ,2 that I may nevermore come into condemnation.

      58. What comfort do you have you from the article of “life everlasting”?

      That, inasmuch as I now feel in my heart the beginning of eternal joy, I shall after this life possess complete bliss, such as eye has not seen, nor ear heard, neither has entered into the heart of man, therein to praise God forever.

      59. What does it help you now, that you believe all this?

      That I am righteous in Christ before God, and an heir of eternal life.

      60. How are you righteous before God?

      Only by true faith in Jesus Christ; that is, although my conscience accuse me, that I have grievously sinned against all the commandments of God, and have never kept any of them, and am still prone always to all evil; yet God without any merit of mine,4 of mere grace, grants and imputes to me the perfect satisfaction, righteousness, and holiness of Christ,7 as if I had never committed nor had any sin, and had myself accomplished all the obedience which Christ has fulfilled for me; if only I accept such benefit with a believing heart.

      61. Why do you say that you are righteous by faith only?

      Not that I am acceptable to God on account of the worthiness of my faith, but because only the satisfaction, righteousness and holiness of Christ is my righteousness before God1 and I can receive the same and make it my own in no other way than by faith only.

      62. But why cannot our good works be the whole or part of our righteousness before God?

      Because the righteousness which can stand before the judgment-seat of God, must be perfect throughout and wholly conformable to the divine law; but even our best works in this life are all imperfect and defiled with sin.

      63. Do our good works merit nothing, even though it is God’s will to reward them in this life and in that which is to come?

      The reward comes not of merit, but of grace.

      64. But does not this doctrine make men careless and profane?

      No, for it is impossible that those who are implanted into Christ by true faith, should not bring forth fruits of thankfulness.

      Belgic Confession art. 37:

      Finally we believe, according to God’s Word, that when the time appointed by the Lord is come (which is unknown to all creatures) and the number of the elect is complete, our Lord Jesus Christ will come from heaven, bodily and visibly, as he ascended, with great glory and majesty, to declare himself the judge of the living and the dead. He will burn this old world, in fire and flame, in order to cleanse it.

      Then all human creatures will appear in person before the great judge—men, women, and children, who have lived from the beginning until the end of the world.

      They will be summoned there by the voice of the archangel and by the sound of the divine trumpet. For all those who died before that time will be raised from the earth, their spirits being joined and united with their own bodies in which they lived. And as for those who are still alive, they will not die like the others but will be changed “in the twinkling of an eye” from “corruptible to incorruptible.”

      Then “the books” (that is, the consciences) will be opened, and the dead will be judged according to the things they did in the world, whether good or evil. Indeed, all people will give account of all the idle words they have spoken, which the world regards as only playing games. And then the secrets and hypocrisies of men will be publicly uncovered in the sight of all.

      Therefore, with good reason the thought of this judgment is horrible and dreadful to wicked and evil people. But it is very pleasant and a great comfort to the righteous and elect, since their total redemption will then be accomplished. They will then receive the fruits of their labor and of the trouble they have suffered; their innocence will be openly recognized by all; and they will see the terrible vengeance that God will bring on the evil ones who tyrannized, oppressed, and tormented them in this world.

      The evil ones will be convicted by the witness of their own consciences, and shall be made immortal—but only to be tormented in the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels.

      In contrast, the faithful and elect will be crowned with glory and honor. The Son of God will “confess their names” before God his Father and the holy and elect angels; all tears will be “wiped from their eyes”; and their cause—at present condemned as heretical and evil by many judges and civil officers—will be acknowledged as the “cause of the Son of God.”

      And as a gracious reward the Lord will make them possess a glory such as the heart of man could never imagine.

      So we look forward to that great day with longing in order to enjoy fully the promises of God in Christ Jesus, our Lord.

  4. The historically sustained relentless push-back on our being ‘justified by grace’ (see Rom. 3:24. Titus 3:7) shows the spiritual battle line for the gospel once delivered to the saints, for which we must contend just as relentlessly. Our assurance is ‘Our God shall fight for us’, and that the Spirit is Lord, and is gathering God’s elect from every corner of the world.

Comments are closed.