How The Tide Is Shifting (And Not In A Good Way)

As I mentioned in the latest episode of the Heidelcast, I am not a big fan of Oral Roberts (1918–2009). Please do not misunderstand me. He is a great American success story. Born in poverty, in Oklahoma, he helped to impel a major religious movement (Pentecostalism) in the USA. He founded a broadcasting empire, a university, a medical center, and a retirement center. He was a classic American religious entrepreneur. He might have been born at the turn of the 19th century as well as at turn of the 20th century. His theology, piety, and practice were right out of the Second Great Awakening. In March, 1987 he announced that he had, as all good Pentecostals and Charismatics do, received a “word from the Lord.” That word was the Lord would “call” him “home” if he did not raise $8,000,000 for medical scholarships. According to the wire service coverage from the period, he was filmed climbing to a “sparsely furnished” spot half-way up the “prayer tower” to fast and pray for the remaining $1.3 million. He did well for himself. Through the 1980s and 90s the empire flourished. By the early 2000s, however, longstanding questions about finances and management re-emerged as the school was $50,000,000 in debt even Roberts had a nice mansion in Beverly Hills.

Roberts’ dubious theology and fiscal management notwithstanding, every American who still believes in the founding principles of this country ought to come to the aid of Oral Roberts University. Indeed, once upon a time, that is exactly what such organizations as the American Civil Liberties Union would have done. Why?  Hemal Jhaveri, in the pages of USA Today, has called for the exclusion of the Oral Roberts University men’s basketball team from the NCAA tournament on the basis that ORU’s traditional ethic, influenced by the holiness and pentecostal traditions (of which Jhaveri apparently knows nothing), offends her late-modern sensibilities. ORU forbids homosexual activity and it also forbids heterosexual sex outside of marriage. Jhaveri calls such prohibitions “antiquated.” So, President Obama’s objection, on professedly religious grounds, in 2008, to homosexual marriage also places him outside the pale? Should he be cancelled because he once held religious views that Jhaveri now finds objectionable?

That Oral Roberts wants to keep its students tied to toxic notions of fundamentalism that fetishize chastity, abstinence and absurd hemlines is a larger cultural issue that can be debated. What is not up for debate however is their anti-LGBTQ+ stance, which is nothing short of discriminatory and should expressly be condemned by the NCAA.

“Toxic.” “Fetishes.” “Discriminatory.” “Condemned.” There is more:

Yet, Oral Roberts, with its decrees banning homosexual conduct, stating that marriage is only between a man and a woman, and specifically banning male students from wearing makeup, earned a ticket to the Big Dance even though the university’s foundations expressly go against the very things the NCAA say they value. The fact is, any and all anti-LGBTQ+ language in any school’s polices should ban them from NCAA competition.

Any institution that holds anything like the historic Christian sexual ethic should be banned from NCAA competition? Who died and made the NCAA the arbiter of morality? Of course ORU discriminates but so does Hemal Jhaveri. She is calling upon the NCAA to discriminate against ORU. Incoherence, thy name is Jhaveri.

My scope here is to note the rapidly shifting cultural norms in which Christians are conducting their pilgrimage. It is also to say that those Christians who think that they can, to shift metaphors, surf the latest cultural tide to remain “relevant” are quite mistaken. The good news is that there is, as they say in football, daylight between the pagans and the Christians. There was a time when polite society required Americans to pretend to sympathize with historic Judeo-Christian ethical norms, even as they defied them privately. That time is past. The truth is that Christians who understand and believe Christian ethical norms are a diminishing lot. We might wish that the postmillennialists were right but all the evidence is to the contrary. Much of evangelical cultural engagement has been driven by the transformational model but transformationalism, at least as it was originally envisioned, has evidently failed. Judging by recent events at Calvin University, the culture is transforming the transformationalists. Whom would Kuyper have supported, the students at the table or the students who were outraged? If you hesitated you do not know Kuyper. My friend Lester Cahill is correct. Christians should take a lesson from Black American experience. Black Americans were subjugated, humiliated, marginalized and still, despite all that was done to them, they developed their own banks, their own schools, and their own cultural institutions. Christians can do the same. If the NCAA will not have ORU perhaps Christian institutions should not have the NCAA? We should not ignore the tide represented by this scurrilous editorial.

There was a time, not very long ago, when the editorial screed published by USA Today would have been unthinkable. For much of the 20th century, the USA was at war with fascism (actual fascism, not the guy in the Starbucks line with a hat you do not like) and later, during the Cold War, with Communism. During those decades there was a great emphasis on the classic American definition of liberty, i.e., the relative absence of restraint. The old American assumption was that one was free to do as one willed so long as there was no law to the contrary. Today, that assumption is largely unknown in the blue states, where the assumption is just the opposite: we may only do what the government permits. In the wake of the wars against tyranny—we saw a resurgence of the old way of thinking, briefly, after 9/11—Americans would have been loathe to publish such a piece because it would have been seen for what it is: an attempt to shame and exclude Americans from participation in society on the basis of their religious beliefs. That is just what the Fascists and the Communists did. That is un-American. Now, the un-Americans, those who flatly reject the principles on which the country was founded, are in charge of the culture and they are feeling their oats. They will go as far as and as quickly as Americans permit them and we Americans permit them when we elect them and empower them politically, culturally, and financially.

Christians need to know where they are and where they are not. This is not Eisenhower’s America. This is not Reagan’s America. We no longer live in Clinton’s America—remember the RFRA? We do not even live in Obama’s America. The whipsaw from Obama to Trump and back again (so far, the Biden Administration makes the Obama Administration look positively conservative) has left us in a strange new world where the reigning morality of the elites regards rejection of same-sex relations and marriage and the rejection of the transgender ideology—we have a transgender cabinet secretary—as immoral. The old Wesleyan and Pentecostal holiness codes are a “fetish.” A man pretending to be a woman is fine but abstinence from sexual immorality is “toxic.” ORU plays Arkansas this Saturday. Despite their allegedly backward Christian ethics, ORU managed to make to the “Sweet Sixteen.” They defeated Ohio State and a stout Florida team. It would be a shame if Christian schools were no longer able to participate in NCAA-sanctioned sports but there is a larger question afoot here.

Resources

    Post authored by:

  • R. Scott Clark
    Author Image

    R.Scott Clark is the President of the Heidelberg Reformation Association, the author and editor of, and contributor to several books and the author of many articles. He has taught church history and historical theology since 1997 at Westminster Seminary California. He has also taught at Wheaton College, Reformed Theological Seminary, and Concordia University. He has hosted the Heidelblog since 2007.

    More by R. Scott Clark ›

Subscribe to the Heidelblog today!


19 comments

  1. Liberty University also played Arkansas in the first round… did she target and call for their being banned? (I obviously have not read the article.)

  2. Several comments to the previous post about the cake baker vs. the trans-activist focused lawyers and electing public officials who aren’t lawyers in order to help circumvent some of these bizarre torts. In the ORU case the focus will be on the courts, if it comes to that. And the whole issue rests on how they decide, either for or against ORU and/or the NCAA. Since not all judges are elected and some in very important courts are appointed, that is where it all breaks down and there’s nothing anyone can do about it.

  3. RSC – but is that true of SCOTUS, which is a likely destination for some of these cases depending upon the outcome and whether or not lower appeals courts overturn a verdict?

  4. We should take Lester Cahill’s advice because the USA may not be long for this world. It looks an awful lot like a collapsing empire such as those described by Sir John Glubb in “The Fate of Empires” and, at a minimum, there will be upheaval. We will do better if we plan for this.

    The transnational elites in charge of this country may be able to hold it together with coercion in the short term, but its not a functional polity. Its people have no common language, nor borders, nor shared history, nor agreement on a common purpose – all the things Aristotle said a nation needs to have. Its composite ethnic groups, many of recent arrival, are starting to pull it apart. For example, Hemal Jhaveri – who is she? Her grandfathers didn’t exactly make the landing on D-Day nor the one at Plymouth in 1620. The point is, the USA is a polyglot boardinghouse and is disintegrating rapidly. A kingdom divided against itself cannot stand.

    Like you said, we should also stop contributing to institutions that do not support us. For example, it’s nice to watch your college basketball team play in the tournament, but not at all necessary. Back in the day, everyone played amateur sports and fostered real community. Solidarity among Christians would be even better. If one school is banned from the tournament, they should all refuse to participate.

    • Bryce,

      My relatives weren’t on the Mayflower. I’m in favor of immigration and diversity but we need to be united politically in a shared commitment to civil liberties and the founding American principles. Without that, the Republic is in danger.

      Christians should spend less time thinking about how to recover power and more time thinking about how to develop institutions which will enable us to live alongside our pagan neighbors without asking anything of them financially. That is the 1st stick with which they beat us: do as we say or we’ll remove your approved status and you’ll lose funding.

    • My relatives weren’t on the Mayflower. I’m in favor of immigration and diversity

      I don’t see how you can say you’re in favor of immigration and diversity without talking about how much and what effect it has. To me, it makes no sense to add more immigration and diversity at this point. It’s great for billionaires and politicians who would like to divide and rule us while keeping wages low.

      but we need to be united politically in a shared commitment to civil liberties and the founding American principles.

      Great idea, but that ship has sailed. That was possible while the dominant factions and ethnic groups in the US believed in it.

      Without that, the Republic is in danger.

      The Republic is dead.

      • Bryce,

        Ethnicity is not a predictor of ideological commitment to American civil principles.

        Of course we must distinguish between legal and illegal immigration. I’m well aware of the effects of the latter.

        There are ideological tests to be condidered. E.g., Islamists, which is a religio-political affiliation, pose a potential threat.

        I agree that we should consider the social-economic consequences of legal and illegal immigration.

  5. Agreed Bryce. America has been infiltrated by the Left with tactics of massive immigration which weaken our countries principles of freedom and equality. The Left corrupts and perverts the principles and constitution in such a way as to nullify it all. It is sort of like “sin” which has corrupted the whole creation. They use our own laws now against our own citizens, our own country.

  6. I attended (and graduated from) Oral Roberts University from 1985 – 1989. While I was there, ORU sent the law school to Pat Robertson because they were being hounded with lawsuits by the homosexual lobby. Not long after Oral Roberts asked for the millions of dollars to fund his Medical School, he had to close it down as well.

    1987 was an interesting time with scandals at PTL and Robert’s financial announcement. When I came back from spring break that year, the media was all over the campus. The next year, Oral Roberts interjected himself into the Swaggart affair because Swaggart had criticized Roberts for being cooped up in the Pray Tower like a “big bird” while he waited for his funding to come in. I think that was the beginning of the contraction of ORU. A university president’s job is to raise money and Richard Roberts did not have the same gravitas as his father.

    The school seems to be on better financial footing these days. I do not think they will roll over when the “morally superior” crowd comes with their lawsuits.

  7. Re: the breakdown of values and the imposition of an authoritarian agenda on the United States, keep in mind, by some estimates there are 700 million firearms in this country among the citizenry. There has never been a country so empowered to deter a tyrannical regime, in the history of the world.

    I don’t think the majority of Americans are going to rest content like a frog in a pan of warm water forever. Eventually nutty ideas will begin to cost lots and lots of money. If the solution is as radical as the problem, I would not want to be a part of the problem.

  8. Re: Hemal Jhaveri, I thought Oral Roberts University was the number one problem facing America. Now I’m learning it is also USA Today? Next I suppose we’ll learn that there is corruption in the Biden administration!

  9. I just read about this writer and her article last Thursday or Friday. Then in news on Saturday, I saw that a USA Today writer was fired. It turned out to be this same writer, Hemal Jhaveri. She had tweeted something about “white guys with guns” in the shooting early last week. Turns out I believe the shooter was a Syrian national if I recall. And now I see that there’s a link to this same story in the first comment above.

Comments are closed.