While we, some of us anyway, are still on Covid-19 lockdown and unable to gather for public worship it is perhaps a time to think about the nature of public worship. Our patterns of life have been disrupted. I suppose that some of us have gone through a sort of withdrawal and even a grieving process over the loss of public worship. Going forward, in most places, public worship will likely not be the same, at least for a while, for those that a permitted by public health authorities to gather for worship. Congregations may be smaller due to social distancing rules. Singing will be a little more complicated by masks. I assume that, in some places, those who are used to worship services that are large productions, where the service is in two parts, singing contemporary worship songs for 30 minutes followed by a message may see some adjustment.
One of the the basic distinctions that the Reformed have made since the 16th century is between those things that are essential to worship and those things that are circumstances in worship. Something is essential to worship if, without it, there is no worship service. According to the Reformed understanding of Scripture, the Word of God is essential to worship. The Word alone is the final authority for Christian worship. In his Word God reveals whom it is that we worship and how he will be worshiped. In Exodus 4 the Lord revealed to Moses why the Old Covenant church was being sovereignly, graciously, freely saved out of bondage from Egypt: that they might worship him (Ex 4:21‐22). He also revealed how he will be worshiped:
I am Yahweh your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery. You shall have no other gods before me. You shall not make for yourself a carved image, or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth. You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I, Yahweh your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, but showing steadfast love to thousands of those who love me and keep my commandments (Ex 20:2–5).
The prologue of the Ten Commandments reveals the gospel, the good news of God’s gracious and free salvation of his people. In its normative (third) use, the moral law reveals how our Savior will be worshiped. The same God who delivered us, his Old Covenant church, out of Egypt is the same God who delivered us at Calvary. Jude 5 says so: “Now I want to remind you, although you once fully knew it, that Jesus, who saved a people out of the land of Egypt, afterward destroyed those who did not believe.”
We approach God only through mediation of his only and eternally begotten Son, Jesus, in the Holy Spirit (John 4:23). In the Word read, preached, and made visible (in the two divinely instituted sacraments, holy baptism and holy communion) the Lord comes to us and by repeating his Word back to him we respond in prayer. Without the Word, there is no proper worship. A service that is not normed by the Word is what the Apostle Paul calls “will worship” (ἐθελοθρησκίᾳ). It has the “appearance” of godliness but lacks the substance thereof.
Nevertheless a worship service must be held somewhere, at some time, in some language. These are necessities imposed upon us in the nature of things. This is the definition of an circumstance: a necessity imposed upon us by nature. Most Reformed ministers and elders are (or should be) familiar with the distinction between elements and circumstances but over the course of the last 4 or 5 decades we have lost track of the original meaning and intent of circumstances. It has become common in Presbyterian and Reformed Churches to appeal to the category of circumstance to justify whatever a congregation might want to do in public worship. The category has become so elastic to have lost all meaning.
The original and true intent of circumstance is clear in Westminster Confession 1.6:
…and that there are some circumstances concerning the worship of God, and government of the church, common to human actions and societies, which are to be ordered by the light of nature, and Christian prudence, according to the general rules of the Word, which are always to be observed.
That clause “ordered by the light of nature” signals the limits of meaning of circumstance. What does the “light of nature” teach us about circumstances? It teaches us that there must be an agreed time, place, and language.
- Certainly a worship service must be held at an agreed time. If some of the congregation arrives at 10:00 AM and others in the congregation arrive at 3:00 PM, for the same service, the congregation is not together. To be sure, cultural attitudes toward time vary but even granting a certain latitude, the congregation must be together at the same time in order to worship together in the same service. That is a natural limit and circumstance.
- A congregation must also speak the same language (or at least provide a translator). Were the congregation to speak, in the service, multiple languages without a translator the service would be chaotic. It would not be conducted “decently and in order” (1 Cor 14:40). If the minister speaks French but the congregation does not and there is no translator, the congregation is not edified (1 Cor 14:11).
- The congregation must, however liberal we might be about the schedule, arrive at the same place. This is true even when we try to conduct services online (whether this experiment has been advisable is a discussion for another time). We must be at the same place (whether really or virtually). This limit is imposed on us by nature. If we are not together, we are not a congregation and what we are doing is not a worship service
As originally intended and as observable in the nature of things, the category of circumstance is not endlessly malleable. Electricity is a convenience not a natural necessity. Sound equipment is a convenience, not a natural necessity. By confusing convenience with necessity there has been much mischief done to and in Reformed and Presbyterian public worship services under the guise of “circumstances.”
- How To Subscribe To Heidelmedia
- On Elements and Circumstances
- Resources On The Rule Of Worship
- Resources On Psalm Singing
- New Film—Spirit And Truth: A Film About Worship