Recovering The Realism Of Natural Law

The Christian natural law tradition offers Christians meaningful and coherent moral guidance apart from instrumental calculations of political power and success. That is, the tradition is moral, not consequentialist or ad hoc. Moreover, rooted in a creational theology, it provides important pathways for a cultural apologetic—a means of making its claims comprehensible to those who disagree. This is vitally important in a political season marked by polarization and tribalism. An evangelical natural law tradition can help reconcile such moral guidance with the norms and processes of a liberal democratic order that takes divergent ultimate commitments seriously and serves the common good, not a sectarian good.

In short, we believe the way forward requires looking back.

Christians have long framed their understanding of the nature and purpose of political life in terms of the natural law. Since the early Church, they have acknowledged that humans, by God’s creational design, inhabit a world in which moral norms and obligations help direct us toward our flourishing, and we can derive meaningful political guidance from these truths. Our attempt to articulate a distinctively evangelical understanding of the natural law draws on this long history of Christian reflection and appropriates that tradition in ways consonant with the best of evangelical belief and practice.

Ours is a theory of the natural law that is characterized by both hope and realism. It is hopeful insofar as it is unequivocally moral, relying on creational norms as guidance for human action toward a vision for human flourishing. This hope animates and directs our actions to human goods and takes seriously the idea that the political order has an important role to play in our flourishing. It is realist insofar as it recognizes the consequences of the Fall and the tensions of our moment in redemptive history. These realities temper our expectations for the present, foreclosing any easy moral or political perfectionism. Here, we find St. Augustine a particularly helpful guide—particularly insofar as he both participates in the best of the natural law tradition and emphasizes evangelical distinctives like the unique authority of Scripture and the deep impact of sin on human will and cognition.

Consider, first, the created order and its relation to political life. We take it that the created order is fundamentally good and intelligible. Much of what is good for human beings in terms of life in the body and in society can be understood through general revelation and is shared among all humans (not just Christians). For all the challenges of perceiving, sharing, and applying creational norms (and the Fall produces many such challenges!), we cannot escape the reality that all humans are bound by moral truths that we cannot entirely wish away, ignore, or misconstrue.

Read More»

Jesse Covington, Bryan McGraw and Micah Watson | “Hopeful Realism: Renewing Evangelical Political Morality” | July 21st, 2022


RESOURCES

Heidelberg Reformation Association
1637 E. Valley Parkway #391
Escondido CA 92027
USA
The HRA is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization.


Subscribe to the Heidelblog today!


3 comments

  1. The following article written by an agnostic, pagan (her words, not mine) which is very similar to this great article that you posted. She just comes at it from a different worldview, but as Jesus told the Scribe in Mark, I would say about this lady, you are not far from the kingdom of God. I highly recommend this article, and let’s pray for this lady.

    https://www.firstthings.com/article/2023/10/we-are-repaganizing

  2. “America is well on its way toward becoming significantly more secular, less just, and less stable…”

    Ordo Ab Chao. We needn’t help stoke these flames.

    Living out our faith locally is our best remedy. It’s the only tool of engagement that truly makes any sense, in my humble opinion.

    • Sidebar: natural law vs neutral law. (Both are necessary).

      If (neo)paganism is leading the state and becoming established religion then there is no neutrality. If natural LAW is not respected unto human flourishing the state becomes self-defeating. (Ultimately, nobody is above the law… death will have the final say).

      The overarching problem is 2-fold:

      1. Paganism is the sworn god of many in power, hence a default religion of sorts is rising.
      2. Their god does not want human flourishing to occur. It actually is actively plotting its (humanity’s) demise & destruction- body & soul.

      That’s why I’m in favor of local pushback and inconvenient truth.

      Humbly push against lies, expose the spiritual source of the lies (and the earthly entities that serve em) and promote the True Good as the Source & Enabler/Sustainer of all good things. The state is not the church but it must (ultimately) serve it.

      The solution starts with a T, but it’s not Theonomy… It’s Transparency. Shine a light – expose darkness (in ourselves & outside of us) and promote The Light.

      The Natural Lawgiver cannot be denied regardless. So we live and we pray each day knowing where our help comes from.

      Our Constitutions & systems of government are not the problem – it’s the plotters and manipulators that are secretly and publicly dismantling it, the family, etc., etc…

      The battle is ours to fight/combat/endure and we cannot do it alone. We press on….

Comments are closed.