Reformation Day Myths

by on October 28, 2026 | Comment

Each year on this date, confessing Protestants remember Martin Luther’s protest against the abuse of indulgences. It is called Reformation Day, and it deserves our attention.

Myth 1

On October 31, 1517, Luther hammered the Ninety-Five Theses to the door of Castle Church.

Fact: People usually say that Luther nailed his Ninety-Five Theses to the church door in Wittenberg. It is possible and perhaps likely that Luther never actually nailed his theses to the church door at Wittenberg. Modern scholars have little confidence that he did so. It seems certain, however, that he mailed them to Albert, the archbishop of Mainz and Magdeburg.

Myth 2

The nailing/mailing of the theses was a dramatic choice by Luther.

Fact: Luther was following the academic custom of the day by compiling a list of theses, which are short statements or claims. Proposing theses was part of the academic process. Students and faculty often held disputations, and protesting against something like the abuse of indulgences was a reasonable and typical thing to do, similar to how doctoral students today (in North America) publicly defend a dissertation before faculty and peers. Somehow, though, mailing theses does not seem quite as revolutionary as nailing them. Perhaps Americans in particular are attracted to the image of Luther and his hammer because nailing a document to a door seems like an American thing to do, like dumping tea in Boston Harbor.

Myth 3

The Ninety-Five Theses were about justification by faith alone.

Fact: Most confessing Protestants probably have not read the Ninety-Five Theses, which is just as well. They are mostly disappointing from a Protestant perspective. You will not find much there about justification by grace alone (sola gratia), or by faith alone (sola fide), or Scripture alone (sola Scriptura) as the sole magisterial authority for the Christian faith and the Christian life. What you will find are a lot of complaints about the way the late medieval church had abused Christians, their consciences, their pocketbooks, and God’s grace as part of a corrupt money-raising scheme to fund, among other things, St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome. Next time you marvel at the beauty of those sixteenth-century buildings in Rome, remember indulgences.

Myth 4

Luther set out to break with Rome and start a new church.

Fact: The Ninety-Five Theses struck a nerve and were widely disseminated and read. Luther said that when he wrote the Ninety-Five Theses, he was still a “right-roaring papist.” He was right. He attacked the system of indulgences and the papacy’s claim to the right to administer it, but what Luther said was not all that revolutionary. He and others had said similar things before. He was not attempting to start a new church.

Myth 5

Luther was the first to make the claims in the Ninety-Five Theses.

Fact: Others had made the same criticisms well before Luther did. His approach to the criticisms was typical, but the revolutionary part was that the Ninety-Five Theses were translated into German and printed on a new, high-tech machine called the printing press. This providential timing allowed Luther’s words to spread far more widely than those of previous reformers.

Myth 6

The Reformation started with Luther and his Ninety-Five Theses.

Fact: Reformation Day, as we know it, perpetuates the pietist myth that the Reformation happened suddenly, in one fell swoop of religious experience (the so-called Turmerlebnis). That is not the way it happened. The Reformation doctrines developed gradually between 1513–21. In succession, and with fits and starts, Luther gradually realized the great Reformation solas. We are not familiar with all of the Reformation solas. Luther’s first breakthrough came during his lectures on the Psalms, when he realized that Scripture teaches we are not just a little sinful but completely sinful—that is, that the effects of sin are radical and affect every human faculty. We are not able to “do our part” or to “do what lies within us” toward justification because, as a consequence of the fall, all that lies “within us” is sin and death. Therefore, the first Reformation sola was “solely unable.” This is the essential assumption behind sola gratia, the claim that justification is by grace alone. Grace is no longer to be reckoned as a sort of medicinal stuff with which we are injected, with which we cooperate toward eventual justification. Luther came to understand that grace is God’s attitude of favor toward sinners. Grace is not something with which we are infused. Rather, God is gracious toward us. He shows us favor. He gives us what we do not deserve: righteousness and life.

Myth 7

The Reformation was a moral cleanup of a corrupt church.

Fact: Moral reform movements abounded in the late Middle Ages and early sixteenth century, but the Reformation was not one of them. The Reformation was a theological event with moral consequences, but it was not first and foremost about moral self-improvement and tidying the ecclesiastical house. Beware all the various “reform” movements in our churches today that want to turn the Reformation into moral renewal (and most of them do). Beware when folk invoke a “new” Reformation and do not understand the old one. Beware when folk call for a Reformation that requires a repudiation of the first Reformation. These movements abound.

Myth 8

October 31, 1517, is the day to remember what the Reformation stood for.

Fact: One of the global changes that occurred at the time of the Reformation was the turn to Scripture as the magisterial and unique authority for faith and life (sola Scriptura). There is no single point at which this view developed, but Luther’s stand for the sole and unique magisterial authority of Scripture at the Diet of Worms in 1521 certainly symbolized it. So it is unfortunate that October 31 has become the day for Protestants to remember why we seceded from the Roman communion (or why she lapsed from the holy catholic church). We would do better to remember the Diet of Worms—which would open a whole new realm of possibilities for Reformation Day celebrations—where Luther stood up for the basic Reformation principles, even if he probably did not actually say, “Here I stand. I can do no other. God help me.” Sorry to be such a killjoy, but this is what historians do.

Myth 9

Reformation Day is the Reformed alternative to Halloween.

Fact: As I just explained, October 31 was not the start of the Reformation, which really began with Luther’s appearance at the Diet of Worms on April 17–18, 1521. Regardless, we are probably stuck with this Reformation Day. Every year I wonder if Reformation Day is not just a way for folks to avoid Halloween. I am ambivalent about Halloween. I do not know if my ambivalence is justified or not, but whatever fundamentalist may yet be running about my conscience has nothing to do with Reformation Day.

Reformation Day is a fine thing, but we should remember what the Reformation was: the assertion and defense of the truth that justification of sinners is by unmerited divine favor alone; that in the act of justification, faith justifies by receiving and resting and trusting in Christ alone; and that Scripture is the magisterial and unique authority for faith and the Christian life. These things are worth celebrating at any time.

©R. Scott Clark. All Rights Reserved.

RESOURCES

Heidelberg Reformation Association
1637 E. Valley Parkway #391
Escondido CA 92027
USA
The HRA is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization

    Post authored by:

  • R. Scott Clark
    Author Image

    R.Scott Clark is the President of the Heidelberg Reformation Association, the author and editor of, and contributor to several books and the author of many articles. He has taught church history and historical theology since 1997 at Westminster Seminary California. He has also taught at Wheaton College, Reformed Theological Seminary, and Concordia University. He has hosted the Heidelblog since 2007.

    More by R. Scott Clark ›

Subscribe to the Heidelblog today!


Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments are welcome but must observe the moral law (Matt 22:37–40). Comments that are profane, that deny the moral law, that deny the gospel, that advance positions contrary to the Reformed confession, or that irritate the management are subject to deletion. Please use a working email address so we can contact you, if necessary, about content or corrections.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.