The church of the second century was facing myriad threats. Persecution, slander, and death were among the commonplace occurrences of Christians’ lives. A different threat was on the horizon, however—the crisis of complacency. The ruling of Emperor Trajan to outlaw Christianity yet require legal proceedings for their persecution made such proceedings, generally, low priority. Thus, ‘fleeing from the hands of God’2 and living in one’s former pursuits became an easy way to elude such charges. This tendency threatened the core of the Christian community. Even in Pliny the Younger’s communication with Trajan, he recognized the strict moral practices against fraud, theft, and adultery which united the Christians he was interrogating.2 So, in order to encourage Christians unto upright living and, consequently, unto unification, many church fathers turned to a long, odd, unique book about the visions of a freedman, Hermas.3 Presented to new converts and those who needed elementary instruction, The Shepherd of Hermas was received with high praise and used to strengthen the communal bonds of a church needing to persevere. Irenaeus, Clement of Alexandria, Athanasius, and Origen thought this book was extremely useful for unification.4 They also used The Shepherd to support doctrines such as creation ex nihilo,5 the knowledge of general revelation,6 and even to develop doctrines of repentance. Its peculiar style, frequent utilization of symbolism, and at times obscure and cryptic rationale led to varied reception. Some questioned their salvation post-baptism, others wondered whether they were saved through works or through faith, and still others searched the text for the person of Christ without finding him. Thus, because of its vague theology, The Shepherd slowly fell out of use and was even condemned by several early theologians, such as Tertullian.7 For modern lay Christians, these issues limit interaction with the book. Yet the praise that early Christians gave it, along with its real or apparent contradictions and odd style, yields many fascinating questions that have spurred large swaths of historians and theologians to seek out its appeal.
I argue that Hermas’s role within The Shepherd was a surrogate for his intended audience,8 judged by the narrative’s own standards as faithless, grief-ridden, and evil-minded, then set on a course of repentance toward the Son of God. This interpretation brings Hermas’s deep-rooted failures to the forefront of The Shepherd and, therefore, challenges the reader to consider their own failures with a view toward repentance and faithfulness. After surveying various interpretations of the Shepherd, we will look at the particular moral standards of The Shepherd in the Twelve Mandates, focusing on the themes of faith, fear, and self-control along with their counterparts. Finally, we will see how Hermas identifies with his audience in each section of the Visions, Mandates, and Parables as a double-minded, weak-in-faith, grieving sinner corrected by the Shepherd and set on a slow path of repentance toward joy and youthfulness.
Interpretations
In the early twentieth century, the prevailing opinion was that Hermas functioned as a prophet with several minor faults. Medieval historian, William Wilson (1884–1963) thought the character had “many splendid qualities” and generally downplayed Hermas’s faults, saying, “All prophets are human.”9 He also judged Hermas’s imperfections according to a moral standard apart from the document itself. He concluded that Hermas was temperamental, short-tempered, and shallow but still an exemplary prophet. New Testament scholar and church historian, Kirsopp Lake (1872–1946) likewise viewed Hermas as a character in a somewhat sympathetic light as “The Reformer.”10 This view of Hermas as an understandably sinful prophet slowly gave way to a consideration of The Shepherd’s theology, with a special focus on Christology, post-baptismal sin, and repentance.
These three topics are certainly important questions for The Shepherd, but New Testament scholar Carolyn Osiek argued that “the book is most properly catalogued as a step along the way to later penitential discipline” rather than a “promulgation of a second repentance.”11 She also maintained that it shows literary unity, citing the singular purpose of addressing mediocrity in Christians, the particular version of apocalypticism it uses, and its unified cosmic eschatology. Similarly, patristic scholar Caroline Buie focused on the function of The Shepherd for the unification of the church. She said, “Hermas’s goal was to unify the church in faith to prepare for the imminent Parousia and possible martyrdom.”12 She further argued that Hermas’s view of ecclesiology is synthesized in four major aspects: purity, perseverance, unity, and avoiding complacency.13 Thus, she concluded that The Shepherd was instrumental in sustaining faith in the Creator as the driving force for the church’s development as a unified community.
Finally, in the late twentieth century, theologian Ramsey Michaels (1931–2020) recognized that little attention had been given to the thematic language that The Shepherd employs—namely, the “level ground” (ὁμαλός) and “rocky ground”—as either righteous or unrighteous. In doing so he connected Hermas’s language with Jewish understandings of righteousness and unrighteousness, primarily in the Old Testament Psalms and Prophets.14 He also placed this study in the context of Hermas’s views on the “second repentance” and assumed that this doctrine was the sole purpose of the book rather than the generally ecclesial purpose that later scholars recognized. The moral standard for this ecclesial purpose of reunification is disclosed in The Mandates, to which we will now turn.
Hermas as the Audience Surrogate
The Mandates (26–49)15 divulge what righteousness is in The Shepherd through three primary lenses of faith, fear, and self-control, with their counterparts: double-mindedness, grief, and evil desire.16 “Believe in him, therefore, and fear him, and fearing him, exercise self-control.”17 These three lenses require brief definitions based on The Shepherd’s descriptions. Faith, for Hermas, is trusting God as the powerful creator, being sensitive and pure, discerning, ultimately powerful, clothed with truth, and—metaphorically—a straight and level path (ὁμαλός).18 Faith is further connected with patience, sweetness and usefulness.19 Its counterpart, double-mindedness, is all that is contrary to faith’s description, but it is also frequently connected with being foolish, empty, hesitating in asking God for something, and—metaphorically—a crooked and rocky path.20 Fear of God, for Hermas, is primarily inquiry into divine matters and loving truth.21 Its counterpart, grief, is characterized by not searching for truth, being wealthy like the outsiders, having impurity, and—metaphorically—having thorns and weeds.22 Self-control, for Hermas, is controlling a list of evils that importantly include arrogance and is actively defined as doing good—that is, obeying the other mandates.23 Self-control is further identified with sincerity, innocence, and purity.24 Its counterpart, evil desire, is signified by lacking understanding, being entangled in this world, desiring another’s wife, and pursuing luxury.25 Hermas’s journey with the angel of repentance can be interpreted through these three lenses of faith, fear, and self-control.
Each major section of The Shepherd begins by presenting Hermas as a righteous and upright prophet. In each, he then realizes his faults and reckons with them, yielding a new righteous and upright state. Beginning with the Visions (1–25), Hermas initially thinks his desires concerning Rhoda are no terrible offence.26 When the vision of the elderly woman comes, she sarcastically introduces him as “Hermas the self-controlled, who abstains from every evil desire and is full of all sincerity and great innocence.”27 The Visions, however, continue to uncover the depths of Hermas’s double-mindedness, grief, and evil desires.28 Each of these three faults are revealed when Hermas receives the word that he sinned greatly by looking lustfully at Rhoda. He is “terribly shaken and upset” and wonders how he can be saved.29 This—according to the Mandates—implies a lack of faith.30 He then debates these things and begins to grieve because of his lack of understanding.31 Finally, the elderly woman who appears to Hermas in Visions 2–4 charges him with the desire for evil deeds.32 She then clarifies what his evil deeds are in 3.1–2 by accusing him of not admonishing his family.33 Thus, Rhoda, the elderly woman, and the Shepherd in chapter 25 recognize Hermas’s sin as double-mindedness, grief, and evil desire, which is then applied to his readers. The elderly woman uses this description in chapter 6 to describe his audience: “All the saints . . . will be forgiven, if they repent with all their heart and drive away double-mindedness.”34 Hermas, therefore, functions as the audience surrogate in the Visions—a stand-in for the double-minded, worldly Christian. After Hermas recognizes his evil deeds, he slowly submits himself to the word of the Lord, and the elderly woman tells him at the end of the Visions, “Do not be confused, but strengthen yourself in my commandments, which I am about to give you.”35
Is Hermas’s recognition and submission at the end of the Visions also the beginning of his repentance? Though it initially seems so, Hermas actually begins his journey at the moment the visions occur. These opening chapters contain several implied repentances at the start of Visions 1–3, which set the tone for the rest of the story. In 1.3; 5.1–2; and 9.4, Hermas travels through a pathless region to a level place (ὁμαλός)—the field. This is metaphorically the journey of the double-minded into faith. In the Two Ways section of the Mandates (35.2–3), the Shepherd says to Hermas, “Follow the straight and level [ὁμαλός] way, and leave the crooked one alone.”36 His journey of repentance, therefore, begins the moment the word about his sin comes to him in the first vision. After the final vision, Hermas is instructed by the Shepherd in The Mandates.
The Mandates begin with a summary of faith, fear, and self-control (26.2); then individual mandates on sincerity, truth, purity, and patience (Mandates 2–5); and finally the powers of faith, fear, and self-control with their respective counterparts (Mandates 6–12). In the first section, Hermas, who was left in the Visions anticipating righteousness, initially appears to submit to the word that comes through the elderly woman (the church).37 As the section proceeds, however, the Shepherd exposes Hermas again as double-minded, filled with grief, and desiring evil.38 This section also develops several nuances of Hermas’s sins. Rather than addressing his ministerial role in correcting the church (his audience), the Mandates are addressed specifically to Hermas. Whereas previously the elderly woman said, “These last words are for the righteous, but the former are for the outsiders and the apostate,”39 in the Mandates the Shepherd says, “Rid yourself of double-mindedness.”40 This section also includes the common refrain of Hermas being called a foolish man, which he eventually concedes to, saying, “I am foolish, sir . . . and I do not understand these parables.”41 This is a stark contrast to his attitude after the correction in the Visions, when he said, “How can I be double-minded when I have been so firmly established by the Lord and have seen glorious things?”42 He now demonstrates a small bit of humility. These glimmers of progress are also present in 27.7, when he was told that his and his family’s repentance must continue to be sincere, pure, and innocent, which implies that he had begun to minister to his family.43 Finally, he finishes the Mandates being tempered by the Shepherd and confesses, “Sir, now I am strengthened in all the Lord’s commandments, because you are with me.”44 Thus, the Mandates continue to identify Hermas as faithless, grieving, and woefully evil-minded; but they offer a strand of hope that he might be recognizing these faults. This leads to the final section, the Parables.
This section of The Shepherd is unique in that Hermas interrupts and questions far more infrequently than in the Visions. Some surmise that this change in frequency indicated multiple authors, but this is more likely a continuation of Hermas’s repentance subtly expressed.45 “For those who hesitate in their relation to God are the double-minded.”46 Through the first five parables, Hermas slowly gains momentum in his questions, and the Shepherd eventually calls him arrogant and fraught with uncertainty.47 Hermas’s recourse is again wondering how a man can be saved.48 This is the third time Hermas asks this question; in the first two instances, he did not receive an immediate answer, whereas here the Shepherd tells him, “God alone has the power to give healing.”49 Thus, he corrects Hermas by enjoining him to faith in the powerful Creator God. Several other moments of failure in this section include his being called double-minded, foolish, and stupid, but these moments are much fewer than in the previous sections.50 After receiving correction with minimal hesitation, Hermas is restored in the final scene. The twelve virgins, which represent the Twelve Mandates, are given to Hermas, who is clothed with their garments, strengthened with their prayer, and returned to his joyful, youthful state.51 Just as the elderly woman slowly became younger and more joyful—eventually sitting rested on a couch—so Hermas slowly returns to the “most holy angel” as he is made joyful like a child. The progress of Hermas’s repentance is likewise indicated by the setting of each major section: The Visions primarily begin on the rocky paths, the Mandates are set in Hermas’s home, and the Parables conclude on his couch. When the angel (an image of the Son of God) who turns Hermas over to Repentance comes to visit him, he sits on the couch—Repentance at his side—and declares to Hermas, “I have turned you and your household . . . over to this shepherd [Repentance].”52 Thus, he concludes the arc of the whole narrative by confirming Hermas’s ministry to his family. Having received righteousness, he gives righteousness.53
Conclusion
In the second century, Trajan’s nuanced decision led many Christians down the path of complacency. As Irenaeus recognized, this path eventually leads to abandoning one’s faith. To rectify this issue, the church was introduced to Hermas, who functioned as a surrogate for the second-century church—double-minded, sinfully fearful, and lacking self-control. In each section of The Shepherd, however, Hermas progresses in subtle ways that lead to his eventual return to the Son of God. His stern correction, slow progress of repentance, and the final image of hope for the reunification of the church inspired many church leaders to teach it to their brothers and sisters in Christ. Similarly, despite its peculiar style, contemporary Christians who might fall prey to moral complacency wrought by religious freedom and lack of persecution can find both correction and hope for unity with one another and with Christ in the odd character of Hermas.
Notes
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies, 4.39.3.
- Pliny, Letters, 10.96.
- This essay uses the name Hermas primarily to refer to the character in the book The Shepherd, not to refer to the author of the work, who could be the same man or not. Scholarship is inconclusive on this point.
- See Edmon L. Gallagher, “Origen on the Shepherd of Hermas,” Early Christianity 10, no. 2 (2019): 201–15; and Caroline Buie, “Hermas’s Purpose: Ecclesiology in the Shepherd of Hermas,” Criswell Theological Review 20, no. 1 (2022): 4.
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies, 4.20.2.
- Clement of Alexandria, Stromata, 2.9.
- Ironically, Tertullian thought that The Shepherd was not harsh enough in its view of post-baptismal sin.
- Hermas does not function as an exemplary character that ought to be modeled—rather, he is a stand-in (or surrogate) for the audience that regularly fails and is critiqued or succeeds and is praised.
- William Jerome Wilson, “The Career of the Prophet Hermas,” Harvard Theological Review 20, no. 1 (1927): 60.
- Kirsopp Lake, “The Shepherd of Hermas and Christian Life in Rome in the Second Century,” Harvard Theological Review 4, no. 1 (1911): 27.
- Carolyn Osiek, “The Genre and Function of the Shepherd of Hermas,” Semeia 36 (1986): 117.
- Buie, “Hermas’s Purpose,” 5.
- Buie, “Hermas’s Purpose,” 22.
- J. Ramsey Michaels, “‘Level Ground’ in the Shepherd of Hermas,” Zeitschrift Für Die Neutestamentliche Wissenschaft Und Die Kunde Der Älteren Kirche 59, nos. 3–4 (1968): 245–50.
- References in parentheses refer to Michael W Holmes, The Apostolic Fathers: Greek Texts and English Translations, 3rd ed. (Baker Academic, 2007).
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 39.1; 40.1; 44.1.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 26.2.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 26.1; 35.2–4; 36.3; 39.10; 43.3; 43.10.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 34.3; 34.6.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 34.1; 35.2–3; 39.4–5, 6, 9, 12.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 28.1; 37.4; 40.4, 6.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 40.4, 6; 42.3.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 38.3, 9.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 27.4; 29.1–9.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 44.1–2, 45.1.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 1.1–5.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 2.4. This introduction is similar to the introduction given to Jonah: “Dove, son of Faithfulness” (יוֹנָה בֶן־אֲמִתַּי) in Jonah 1:1. Jonah acts as an audience surrogate for Israel and, as does Hermas, continues to act exactly contrary to his introduction. This comparison is only surface level as there is no indication that The Shepherd was influenced by the prophet Jonah, and this device is used elsewhere in literature.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas. For double-mindedness, see 1.6; 2.1; 4.2; 6.4–7; 9.1–5; 10.2; 11.4; 12.3; 14.5; 16.9; 17.1; 18.9; 19.3; 22.5; 24.6. For grief, see 1.7; 2.2; 18.6; 21.2; 22.4; 24.7; 25.3–4. For evil desires, see 2.4; 3.1; 6.3.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 2.1. Cf. 28.3; 60.3. This idea is present in the beginning of each new section.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, cf. 40.1.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 2.2.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 2.4.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, cf. 38.3. Though this is not intuitively a lack of self-control, the Mandates list this as one of the active goods that one who is self-controlled must do.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 6.4.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 25.5.
- For an in-depth study of The Shepherd’s use of ὁμολός, see Michaels, “‘Level Ground’ in the Shepherd of Hermas.” Michaels further argues that Hermas’s access to this material was not from the LXX but from an alternate Greek version most closely paralleling Symmachus.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 27.7.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 28.3; 30.1; 40.3–4; 41.1; 46.1; 47.1–3, 5; 48.3.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 4.2.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 39.1 (emphasis added). See also 40.1 and 44.1.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 40.3.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 22.4.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, cf. 38.9; 46.2.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 49.4.
- John Christian Wilson, Toward a Reassessment of the Shepherd of Hermas: Its Date and Its Pneumatology (Mellen Biblical Press, 1993).
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 39.5.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 54.5; 56.1, 6, 8; 57.2–3; 60.4.
- See footnote 28.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 60.8.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 61.2; 64.3; 65.2; 91.4.
- Topics of the Mandates include Faith, Fear, Self-Control, Sincerity, Innocence, Love, Truth, Purity, Patience, and Harmony. The names of the twelve virgins are Faith, Self-Control, Power, Patience, Sincerity, Innocence, Purity, Cheerfulness, Truth, Understanding, Harmony, and Love. See Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 92.2.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 111.2.
- Holmes, Shepherd of Hermas, 9.6.
©Jakob Gilbert. All Rights Reserved.
RESOURCES
- Subscribe To The Heidelblog!
- Download the HeidelApp on Apple App Store or Google Play
- Browse the Heidelshop!
- The Heidelblog Resource Page
- Heidelmedia Resources
- The Ecumenical Creeds
- The Reformed Confessions
- The Heidelberg Catechism
- Remembering the Reformed Confession: Our Theology, Piety, and Practice (Heidelberg Reformation Association, 2026).
- The Heidelberg Catechism: A Historical, Theological, & Pastoral Commentary (Lexham Press, 2025)
- Recovering the Reformed Confession (P&R Publishing, 2008)
- Why I Am A Christian
- What Must A Christian Believe?
- Heidelblog Contributors
- Support Heidelmedia: use the donate button or send a check to
Heidelberg Reformation Association
1637 E. Valley Parkway #391
Escondido CA 92027
USA
The HRA is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization


Thanks. I own Ehrman’s edition of the Apostolic Fathers, and confess that I found Hermas the hardest read.